Hermeneutics Part 2
Continuing the hermeneutics class, Greg turns to postmodern, reader-centered interpretation, where the reader rather than the author decides what Scripture means. He walks through feminist, liberation and gay theology, then warns that evangelicals do the same when charismatics read a second baptism into Matthew 3:11 or a magazine urges a return to Old Testament worship. Against this, he holds that the author's original meaning can be known and that context guards against reading in our own agendas.
- Postmodernism reacts to the liberals and the neo-orthodox, drawing on literary criticism: since the author's intent supposedly can't be known, readers find what they want.
- Social theologies such as feminist, liberation and gay theology reinterpret or reject passages to fit an agenda, as with Luke 10:21 or Romans 1.
- Evangelicals are not immune. Reading a second baptism into Matthew 3:11 ignores the very next verse, and a call to recover Old Testament temple worship forgets that the old covenant has been replaced.
- Reader-centered theories make the reader the authority over Scripture. They admit their bias, and they are right that most people read into the text.
- The answer is that the author's original intended meaning can be determined, with a single interpretation, which leads into the grammatico-historical method next time.
Also read
Do you believe in the little resurrection? Sure. This article in here.
Episcopalian. The guy went from an evangelical to the Episcopalian church? Yeah. We'll get to that next time. I thought he said the NASB was better. I found that odd, and I realized I was reading Grant Osborne. But still, it's interesting to read that because we'll talk about it. Yeah. Okay, let's go. Keith, can I use the pointer? Do I need to use your... Keith? Just use the pointer? Okay. Okay, now we're moving on into the modern era.
Finally getting to post-war times. The big one. The second big one. And this is getting into, you know, it's entitled here, Ideological Interpretation. You know, Don and Columbus, and now actually if you read, and this is a common term now, it's postmodernism is what it's called. Okay, and this is the postmodern hermeneutic. Now what's interesting about this is this keeps... These guys are just following along. You had the liberals, you had the neo-orthodox. The neo-orthodox was a reaction to the liberals.
Postmodernism is a reaction to essentially all those guys. And what's different about these guys is that their influence comes from literary criticism, not from philosophy. Neo-orthodoxy and liberalism is really a philosophical approach. These guys have their original intentions, so why even waste time doing that? Let's just... Say what we want to say and find what we can. And this is important for us because our whole position is that you can understand what the author's original intent was. You know, when you come to the Bible, it's clearly opposite of that view. And where you see this, is this creeps in now into just about every area.
You know, that is kind of a dry book. It's not real edifying. But it is good because it tells you how this... philosophy creeps in into just about every area of life now it's it's so accepted and the the term for post-modern comes from that it's a reaction to modernism which is rational thinking you know scientific thinking is modernism uh whereas post-modernism is after that and it's not really scientific it's not based on truth and that you can discover truth it's just based on you're going to pretty much get irrational Okay, so here's several examples, and I'm sure you're familiar with a lot of these. Feminist theology. Anybody here familiar with feminism? Feminism.
Feminist theology. And here, they desired... Has anybody read anything from feminist theology at all? Has anybody seen? There's actually a whole theology where they interpret the Bible in light of feminist philosophy and perspective, you know. Yeah. Yeah, Sophia, they're into, you know, wisdom is Sophia's mother wisdom. It's a feminine term. But the thing here, and this is true of all of these, this perspective, is you reinterpret or reject or change around scripture to get what you want. And in this case, they change it around to really either get rid of the patriarchal content, the male-dominated.
Or they reinterpret a different way, you know, so that they say that it's really not a patriarchal content. It depends who you read on this, because they go from, there's both extremes, the people who just reject and the people who just, no, they reinterpret the scripture with patriarchal content. For example, Genesis 2, the woman was created out of the man. Okay, so the feminist theologian is going to go in there and either reinterpret that passage. and say that that's not really a patriarchal thing, that it's not really, it wasn't really that the woman was created out of man. Man is really not above a woman or anything like this. Or they'll reject that passage and say that that's just wrong. You know, and I didn't bring this quote, but there's this one quote, and the lady says, you know, well, even if we are wrong, as long as we stick to our guns and get what we want, it doesn't matter.
You know, and that's pretty much, it's in Dennis' book, it's pretty good.
Right. This is the group that leads, you know, changing God in the Bible. So, yeah, it's coming from this group here. And you'll also find with this group that they support, you know, they'll really emphasize, you know, the women of the Bible, of course. Should I say matriarchal content? No, no, no, patriarchal. They are against male-dominated emphases in Scripture. They're eliminating them. Well, you know, most... They would say most of them. That's what I don't know. Keith made me be concise here.
Oh, oh, oh, oh. Oops. How do I go back? All right. Okay, Okay, yeah. Let's go on.
Liberation. Liberation theology. Has anybody ever heard of this? Never? Really? In the third world, this is real big. Real big, especially in South America. In fact, most of the authors have Spanish, Hispanic names. And their whole perspective is they interpret the Bible and say that the Bible's main focus is the liberation of poor and oppressed classes. And so they go in and say that that's us. And this justifies violence. It justifies overcoming the rich, the wealthy, and the people who are dominating us for all these years, because after all, God is on our side. And that's what Christ came to do, was to liberate people from the tyranny of the wealthy.
And those who are taking advantage of us. Somebody get Luke 10.21.
Yes, Father. For thus it is well pleased with us. Okay. Yeah. Well, when you pray in the NASB, you've got to use flowery language. But how do you think they would interpret that? The babes. Yeah. That's right. They have special revelation that the rest of us in America, for the most part, don't. They have the special revelation, and they're justified in their interpretation. And their big argument is, after all, isn't the Bible written from the perspective of the powerless? And you'd have to say yes. A lot of their critiques, you'd have to agree with.
What they end up saying is salvation is not salvation from one's sins. Salvation is from the oppressors, essentially. And so that's where, right, it's a social theology where you are socially saved, not necessarily, hmm? All this is social theology, feminism. Yeah, I mean, you will find most, almost all, I don't know of any of the social theologies. It's probably not. It doesn't fit into this category because they just have their agenda and they read into the scriptures what they want to read in. Moving on, another social theology.
Gay theology. Anybody ever run into anybody who is a practicing Christian gay? There's churches. There's whole churches just made up of homosexual Christians, essentially. And what they have to do... Here is either reinterpret again parts of the Bible or they just get rid of it in some cases. But you.
reattracted by his biblical knowledge. uh And here, you know, they contrive examples of homosexual relationships in the Bible. After all, you know, Jesus and John were buddies. Yeah, the one whom he loved. The one who put his head on his chest. You know, on his bosom. All right.
David and Jonathan in the Old Testament, of course, were special friends.
Special friends, and there's plenty of these. And, you know, they want to de-emphasize the homosexual passages as well, that you find in the New Testament. Somebody get Romans 1.
Okay.
How would they? What in the past? Okay. Now I got the thing. Oh, there she is. Oh, it's cheese. Yes. Here's their interpretation. The persons Paul condemns are manifestly not homosexual. What he derogates are homosexual acts committed by apparently heterosexual persons. Paul did not discuss gay persons, but only homosexual acts committed by heterosexual persons. Because actually it's the males who started, who were heterosexual. You could read that into the passage that they were.
And so that's how they would interpret that passage. You know, and that's really a stretch. I mean, you really make it. I have to go back. Oh Okay, so that's gay theology. Okay, evangelical Christianity. Is it possible that we in evangelical Christianity can even be tempted by postmodernism? Thank Very much. And as you, I'll say right, well, I'll get to it.
You see this. You know, essentially what I'm getting at here is somebody coming to the text with their own ideology. It's been known forever. It's eisegesis. We'll talk more about that later. But, you know, the charismatics, you know, they overemphasize some passages. They read into other passages. You know, most notably 1 Corinthians 12 and 14 where it talks about gifts of the Spirit. Somebody get Matthew 3 11.
Has anybody ever had a discussion with Charismatic about the second baptism? Second baptism.
Well, this is a passage that many Charismatic groups... he was a Holy Spirit and a player. Okay. This is the Hyper-Pentecostals use this passage. But what's wrong? Now, when we talk about context, this is where context is very important. Yeah, but even from the context, you should be able to say that right off the bat, that this is a wrong... The very next verse, yeah.
Hmm? Which explains what the spirit and what fire is in the very next verse. You know, one is saved, the other is burned with fire. It's a reference to hell, not the second baptism. You don't want to go through the second baptism if you don't have to. That's not good. Yes, and an interesting thing here, too, with experience. Claudia said she just got this Christianity Today article. Their lead article, Missing God at Church. Very interesting. Here's a picture of somebody falling asleep at church. And actually what Keith is talking about, the movement now is for evangelical Christians to go back to the traditional churches where there's nice worship.
And this is what's happening. And this guy is a professor at Wheaton University. He's now an Episcopalian. He was a Baptist. Wheaton is a very, you know. Big evangelical school, you know, very well known, usually fairly highly reputed. And he goes in this article and he says, Say liturgy, and my evangelical college students have a reflex akin to an invitation to take a quiz. Say mysticism, and they are drawn. fascinated eager to see what i mean they want spontaneity yet drift toward the episcopal church they carry niv study bibles but are intrigued by experiments in prayer christian meditation spiritual disciplines honed in the medieval world and candlelit He goes on.
It's very interesting. Now, the whole thing of this is that this is what we need to get back to in evangelical Christianity. And here's his argument for it. Right, they're saying, you know, like he has this quote here, that I believe evangelicals are yearning to recapture worship that lifts us. As a medieval cathedral lifted the eyes, God is big, you know, or we want to see God as big. But here is his argument, listen to this. I tell this story only to suggest, and he tells a story about how he had a positive experience with his kids. looking at the stained glass windows and saying, who are the people on the stained glass windows and explaining them, okay?
I tell this story only to suggest that many worshipers come looking for more than fellowship, exposition, and exhortation. They seek an experience of the holy. They come looking for awe and reverence, mystery and transcendence. Furthermore, many of their sensory faculties need to be engaged. Their senses of sight, sound, touch, and smell are powerful avenues of communication. One glance at the Old Testament directions for orchestrating temple worship will remove all doubt that this is our task. Fire, incense, tapestry, and gold join with ritual activities that remind worshippers of the reverent awe demanded of them. Bells and breastplates provided a visual feast evoking images of God's presence. Even the temple architecture did this. One climbed higher as steps led up to the holy place.
Evangelicals need to reclaim their Old Testament heritage. No. Now, what's the problem with that? Well, even his justification, what's the problem with the justification? The Old Testament. Old Testament. You know, obviously this guy's a covenantal theologian, but he wants to go back to his argument for his Old Testament covenant. And what do we know of the Old Testament covenant? It's done away with. It's been replaced with a new covenant. You know, you can't use the Old Testament word on the way with. But this is, you know, and Christianity Today is really bad on this. They are very wishy-washy in many of their articles.
It's very interesting. They're really into postmodern thought. In fact, some of the guys who critique the books, if you read the guys who critique the books. Most of these guys, I know there's one from Duke University and somewhere else, but they're really postmodernists, and they really get off people, you know, getting into absolute truth and stuff. So be careful what you read out there. Yes, be very critical. And also, what else did I hear? 50% of all born-again Christians do not believe in absolute truth. And this is from something that George Barnett did a year ago or so. You know, and this is an amazing thing. Half of evangelical Christians do not believe that the Bible, do not believe in absolute truth, you know.
And that, you know, I mean, when you come to that, one of our premises is that there is absolute truth, you know, and that God is able to communicate his truth to us, you know. And it's a scary thing now that a lot of people are giving in to this. And the reason is, is because it's very convenient. You know, it allows for a lot of lifestyles and various other things that people get into when they buy into, uh, they're not, well, they don't believe there is such thing. You know, I mean, the Bible says that, that God is true, that God, right. And they're, they would be saying that, you know, they're, they're relative and they're thinking about, you know, what is true, what is not their interpretation of the Bible, you know, um, to fit whatever they're into.
I think another thing I didn't put up here, too, is Christian psychology. You know, there are a lot of things in Christian psychology that what they are, they're secular views that people find a passage for in the New Testament and import it and say, this is what God is all about. You know, you see this a lot in the victim mentality in Christian psychology. There's a lot of this done, as well as, I think, as well, the sense that there's this dignity thing. about people use a lot of passages to show how Christ supported someone's dignity, you know, which is really not there. I think these guys are really reading in to a lot of these passages. That's not the emphasis of Scripture. And, you know, I think, although now there may be, there's certainly dignity may be important, but it's another thing to read into the way Jesus behaved to get your point across.
You know, if you think that's important, just say it's important. But don't try and force it into something that's in the Bible. And that's what a lot of these guys do. Force extra meanings. um So, the critique. Now, this is a reader-centered theory. And they don't mind being called reader-centered theories. A reader-centered theology or anything like that. This is fine. And that's the amazing thing about this. I would be embarrassed, but they aren't. And, you know, as opposed to a text-centered hermeneutic or an author-centered hermeneutic, that's kind of the progression throughout history, but these guys are reader-centered.
The readers are the authorities, not the authors, not the actual words that are being used, but the reader is the authority. uh... and uh... And they're biased. I mean, they just can't get around that there is no one interpretation. You know, you thought liberal and neo-orthodox had a lot of interpretations. These guys have an infinite amount more interpretations than those guys because that's a free-for-all. And whoever's reading it can interpret it whatever way they want.
Now, they would respond to this and say, yes, you're right, I am biased, but at least I'm honest. Everybody else is biased, too. They just don't admit it. So they've been doing this forever. But at least I'm admitting it, and that's just the way it is. And our point here is that, again, we would critique this by saying it is possible to determine the original intended meaning of the author. and that there is a single interpretation that can be drawn from the text. And we'll get into that next time when we get into grammatico-historical hermeneutic, which is what we're advocating for here um But, you know, the fact is they are right.
Like, you know, we've been going through all these things. Most people do read in to the Scripture. You know, and the fact about this is that it does take some energy to kind of get to this point. You know, so, I mean, they do have a point. They have a point that most people are biased and are just pretty much are going to feed in their interpretation or their opinion without much regard for, you know, what is actually the truth behind it or something like that. So this does take a little work.
Yeah, I mean, for these guys, you probably could fit them into. Well, not even just allegorical. Some of them are just blatant. They're just coming in with their... This goes back to you can make the Bible say whatever you want it to say, and they're just going to do that. And you can do that for any document. But yeah, there's relationships to it. Their big thing is that they're pretty open about it. At least the allegorical people thought that they were being spiritual, and they thought they had the deeper meaning. These guys have a purpose behind what they're doing. And, of course, the reader is not under the authority of Scripture. The reader is the authority over Scripture.
You know, and when we get into the next section, yeah. So let's end there. Any questions on this stuff?
What do we have? Yeah, we'll stick around here and turn the baseball game on. Hopefully we're better than we were in the first inning. Well, we'll get to that next time. It means clarity. Oh, let's pray. Anybody want to pray here? Where's that? Ricochet. The other right. That's what we were watching yesterday. The other day. Thank you very much. Right. They were. Barth was the best. Thank Was it Meyer or was it?
I thought it was that Christian Theology Part 1 that we had to read that. Was that it?
Well, yeah, we were supposed to critique it.
I had a lot of fun critiquing it. Yeah.
0:00 /